The Top 5 New American Experiences In The West Loop

## 5 West Loop Tasting Menus That Actually Live Up To The Hype Real talk—the West Loop is almost *too* full of fancy tasting menus. But there are five spots (all within a brisk walk of that eternal Girl & the Goat line) where dinner is so much more than eating tiny courses on custom ceramics. These places all bring their own quirks, showmanship, and occasionally, a bit of delicious chaos. Whether you're saving up for a big night, hunting for your next “special occasion” move, or just sick of scrolling OpenTable and feeling overwhelmed, here's what's really worth your money right now. --- ## 1. [Smyth](https://links.bestofchicago.directory/smyth): Fermentation, Funk, And 3 Stars Without The Attitude  There's a reason food geeks whisper about Smyth like it's a secret society. Chef-couple John and Karen Shields basically invented their own sub-genre of fine dining—one part high-tech ingredient lab, one part memory-soaked feed from a Virginia farm, all delivered in a room that feels like the poshest Airbnb upstate. It's three Michelin stars, but nobody's looking at your shoes or judging your table manners. The playlist drifts from jazz to Jay-Z, and the staff seems genuinely excited to share whatever weird, wonderful thing they just pickled. The menu's 16-ish courses, but don't expect foams-on-everything: one bite might be a kelp tart topped with crunchy trout roe; the next's a beefy doughnut piped with foie mousse and crab. Pro move? Go middle-of-the-week if you can—last-minute tables do exist, and 72 hours' notice for dietary requests is a must. Be emotionally and financially prepared (about $420, plus if you want those wild wine pairings). Is it #worthit? Once in a while, yeah. **What You'll Dream About Later:** That Maine uni set atop a whisper of peach and wasabi. Foie-and-crab doughnut, no contest. Miso-cured quail egg that tastes like breakfast from another planet. --- <div class="bg-slate-50 border border-slate-200 rounded-lg p-6 my-8 list-optin-container"> <div class="mb-4"> <h3 class="text-xl font-bold text-slate-900 mb-1">Join Chicago’s Foodie VIP List</h3> <p class="text-slate-600">Get insider access to chef’s tables, secret menus, and VIP-only deals—like last week’s BOGO on filet mignon at one of the most popular restaurants in River North. Don’t miss out!</p> </div> <form class="list-optin-form" data-list-id="3" data-list-slug="foodie-vip-list"> <input type="hidden" name="list_id" value="3"> <div class="grid grid-cols-1 md:grid-cols-2 gap-4 mb-4"> <div> <label class="block text-sm font-semibold text-slate-700 mb-1">First Name</label> <input type="text" name="first_name" class="w-full border-slate-300 rounded-md shadow-sm focus:border-blue-500 focus:ring-blue-500 px-3 py-2 border" placeholder=""> </div> <div> <label class="block text-sm font-semibold text-slate-700 mb-1">Email Address</label> <input type="email" name="email" class="w-full border-slate-300 rounded-md shadow-sm focus:border-blue-500 focus:ring-blue-500 px-3 py-2 border" placeholder="" required> </div> </div> <div class="flex flex-col md:flex-row items-center justify-between gap-4"> <button type="submit" class="w-full md:w-auto bg-blue-600 hover:bg-blue-700 text-white font-medium py-2 px-6 rounded-md transition-colors shadow-sm"> Get VIP Access </button> <p class="text-xs text-slate-500">We respect your privacy—your info stays private.</p> </div> <!-- Inline Message Area --> <div class="list-optin-message hidden mt-4 text-sm p-3 rounded-md"></div> </form> </div> ## 2. [Oriole](https://links.bestofchicago.directory/oriole): Industrial Hideaway, Theater Of Bites  Blink and you'll miss Oriole's alleyway door. The first “course” is really a Choose Your Own Adventure—buzzed in, into a “freight elevator” that doesn't move, and then boom, the main event: a blacked-out dining room with an open kitchen so dreamy you'll want to move in. Chef Noah Sandoval and his crew choreograph every step, and it's a truly chill environment. No snooty wine-splaining here. You start at the bar (little tartlets and yuzu, welcome drink), pop by the kitchen for a front-row seat to some foie, then settle into your table, like being at a chef-friend's for the most extra dinner party ever. Menus lean luxury—A5 Wagyu, Hokkaido uni, and truffles all get their moment—but what makes Oriole fly is that nothing is fussy for the sake of it; dishes just *work*. At $325 and up, it's a splurge, but the “wow” factor is real. **You'll Tell Friends About:** Capellini threaded with shaved black truffle. Rhubarb showing up as sorbet, granita, and candied—all in one bite. The crispy cracker with octopus carpaccio at the bar (and wondering if you could get a box to go). --- ## 3. [Elske](https://links.bestofchicago.directory/elske): Danish Calm, Chicago Heart  Elske means “love” in Danish, and you feel that from the second you step through the glass doors. There's a patio with ivy, furs, and an outdoor hearth that makes this one of the best al fresco bites in the city (weather permitting, of course). David and Anna Posey invented the West Loop spot for people who want technique *without* pretense. The vibe splits the difference between chic and cozy. They'll happily walk you through a tasting menu (snag it for $140—arguably the best deal amid the stars), but you can also just post up with a la carte shrimp toast and a glass of something wild. Dave does mad scientist savory (smoked arctic char hiding under turnip), while Anna's sunflower parfait with sour honey and licorice haunts dreams. They don't do caviar nonsense; flavor trumps “fancy.” And their nonalcoholic juice pairings, while sometimes a little sweet, show way more effort than the usual soda gun. **Signature Moves:** Duck liver tart with ramp; shrimp toast with nasturtium; creamy barley rosette topped with sea buckthorn (yes, you like sea buckthorn now). --- ## 4. [Next](https://links.bestofchicago.directory/next): Dinner Theater For The Chronically Curious  Next is, quite literally, never the same restaurant twice. The elaborate ticketing system (think concert tix: pre-pay, no backsies, fluctuating prices) is infamous, and the themes jump from “Alinea Year 1” (throwback to the foams-and-gelee era) to Bottura tributes and even—no joke—a future-of-dining-in-space menu. Come for dinner as dinner theater: staff in character, dishes dangling into your mouth, rooms totally redone to match the current story. Not everyone loves the showmanship (or the fact that some “next-level” gimmicks have been spotted at other Alinea Group joints), but if you want a dining room that makes you genuinely question, “Wait, what *is* that?” this is it. Tickets typically run $225–$305 depending on the night, with the best seats for groups at the Kitchen Table. **Must-Experience Bites:** The “Hot Potato, Cold Potato” that's all temperature trickery; truffle explosion raviolo; pork belly spring roll you'll crave for the rest of the year. --- ## 5. [Sepia](https://links.bestofchicago.directory/sepia): Old Souls, New Ideas  Where some new arrivals scream “look at me,” Sepia just sits cool and quietly confident inside a 19th-century print shop decked with art nouveau floors and big, warm woodwork. It's been here longer than most, and chef Andrew Zimmerman's riffs on American, Mediterranean, and Asian ingredients still feel fresh. The four-course prix fixe ($125) is a perfect entry point for anyone new to “fancy” dining: start with chef's choice cured salmon tartlets or beef carpaccio, then chase BBQ sablefish with a sticky toffee pudding finale. If you're feeling adventurous, spring for the chef's creative eight-course menu. Service is dialed in to a tee—friendly, patient, and always ready to offer a wine pairing without making things weird. Sepia is what you want in a special-occasion spot: zero attitude, maximum satisfaction, reliably excellent. **Why You'll Come Back:** Jivara milk chocolate “frosty” with caramelized potato (seriously). That sticky toffee pudding, done right. --- ## Not So Secret: Pro Tips Before You Book **Reservations:** All five take advance bookings—Smyth, Oriole, and Next are strict about it (check TOCK for tickets/slots), and Sepia can book up fast on weekends. Elske, somewhat miraculously, often has shorter-lead-time availability, but don't chance it. **Price Range Cheat Sheet:** – **Splurge zone**: Smyth, Oriole, Next ($225–$475+ once you factor in wine) – **Sweet spot**: Elske, Sepia ($125–$140 before drinks) **Dietary Needs:** Vegan or weird allergies? Oriole usually plays ball *with advance notice*. Next's menus sometimes make swaps tricky. Always email or call 72 hours ahead. **Dress Code:** No suit/tie needed at any—presentable jeans and a jacket work everywhere. This is not River North. **Other heads-up:** Many of the fancier places tack on a 20% service charge—it's not sneaky, it goes to the team. And when in doubt, check their Instagram: menu themes, closing dates, and last-minute cancellations pop up there first. --- ## The West Loop in One Bite All five of these kitchens are different flavors of “only-in-Chicago,” each putting their own spin on what American food can actually be. Whether you want theatrical, genre-bending, or just want to eat like a total baller for one night, the West Loop's got a seat (and probably a snack on a custom spoon) waiting. Not sure where to start? Pick your vibe and go—these are the tables people talk about *after* vacation's over.